The Ohio Supreme Court on Tuesday kicked a Cleveland Municipal Court Judge off the bench and temporarily stripped her of her law license for misconduct.
Pinkey Carr was suspended indefinitely and she has agreed to undergo evaluations of her mental. She had been accused of more than 100 instances of misconduct.
The justices voted 5-2 to indefinitely suspend the law license of Pinkey Carr the vivacious former assistant county prosecutor who became a judge in 2012 after helping send serial killer Anthony Sowell to death row.
The attorney who defended her, Nicholas Froning, argued that the judge’s poor conduct stemmed from untreated sleep apnea, menopause, and mood disorder.
Carr’s misbehavior first came to light as she continued holding court hearings after the onset of the global COVID-19 pandemic forced the courthouse to shut down.
She issued warrants for the arrest of defendants who did not show up to court, despite being told they were not required to because of the coronavirus.
She set bails at $5,000 and $10,000 for defendants who were not in court and then lied and said it was ‘absolutely untrue’ that she had issued said warrants.
She often demeaned defendants and attorneys in her courtroom, calling one attorney who questioned holding court during the pandemic a ‘little idiot.’
‘She conducted court from a bench covered by an array of dolls, cups, and junk novelty items,’ read the filing.
‘She repeatedly waived fines and expunged court reprimands for defendants for arbitrary reasons, including the timing of their birthday’.
‘She once ordered someone to spend 15 days in jail because they rolled their eyes and made a sarcastic remark in her courtroom’.
According to the complaint, ‘She has at various times appeared on the bench wearing workout attire consisting of a tank top and long shorts; or a T-shirt and above-the-knee spandex shorts and sneakers.’
She also made a habit of wearing loud and prominent necklaces and other pieces of jewelry to court, which complimented the myriad flowers, bottles, and other novelty items she kept on her bench’, see video below.
